cablooshe

I play too much complex shit.

I've been working on a board game on and off for the past few years that is about raccoons stealing assorted junk from various locations, ranging from someone's trash cans to an active sinkhole to an underwater expedition. It's been my thing for way too long at this point, and at the beginning of the year I endeavored to finish this thing mechanically, and see what I could do to look into printing some sort of version for myself, at the very least.

In my mind, I very much treat this game as "family friendly". Something that I intend to teach my parents when I fly across the country to see them later this month. In my head I imagine cutesy raccoons trying to operate a forklift carrying the trash down the road of my town. I hope that when I'm finished, I'll be able to share this game with one of my friend's kids, and they'll be able to wrap their 2-3 year old minds around it while also enjoying being raccoons for a bit.

Now here's the problem. I'm writing this article while on my second monitor, I'm watching some other friends play Twilight Imperium 4th edition in a local tournament, and they've been sitting discussing trade deals and the use of Nova Seed for the past hour as the game descends into chaos in round 4(? to be honest I've lost track at this point). Someone is stalling on hitting Imperial, and nobody has scored the only stage 2 that might bring them over the limit to achieve victory.

Does anyone else see the problem with the above two paragraphs?


Personally, I like complex games. I play Netrunner, I've tried to get my local friends into joining me for some Twilight Struggle, and a few folks I know will definitely say that my main source of joy is freezing waves in toplane while playing League. I'm not exactly a fan of "family friendly" games.

What's even worse is that my friends definitely are less into family friendly games. I mean, I did meet most of them when playing the above games myself, so you'd assume they're also the sort of "complex board gamer" that raccoons really isn't built out for.

When I get feedback about the game, people talk about adding cool mechanics, or more combos, or better strategic choice when playing each round. But also like, they'll sometimes recommend adding some crazy shit that adds another 3 pages to my WIP rulebook to get implemented. That's not that great for a game I'd like to be able to put in front of some kids that they can just kind of play off the bat. But they are good ideas, and if I wanted to build something for them and me, I'd definitely put them in.


So, I've got some interesting paths ahead of me:

  • Continue on the "family friendly" track. Dumb down mechanics, try to find new people that want to continually playtest the game (or just find new people constantly). Maybe work on lowering the numbers on everything so there isn't a priority list going from 1 to 150.
  • Embrace the "strategic" side. Do some more hardcore balancing, add more depth to playing and using cards, add more combos, weird effects, more rules.

I think for now, I plan on doing something in the middle of these two. I'm hoping to achieve the best of both worlds. Maybe I'll make something that's fun for all ages! Hopefully something a bit more replayable too.

At the end of the day I like playing my game, and I intend to keep it that way at least for now. Maybe that's not the best way to design for an audience that isn't just me, but hey at least it's a start.


By the way if anyone stumbles on this blog and is actually interested in playtesting for this game, I'm not sure how you'd be able to get in contact with me but you can probably find me on discord or something. Hunt me down and drop me a message!