cablooshe

Tempo and Prison in Netrunner

Jan Tuno just released its excellent book on Ob. It's a fantastic deep dive into the card, and I've been really enjoying it as someone who's been playing the identity for a few years now.

One small section that I've seen a decent amount of discussion on has been defining a standardized set of terms for netrunner players to use in the space. This particular quote drew my attention

Part of what makes writing about Netrunner hard is that terminology is really underdeveloped, and mostly based on folksonomies that haven’t really stayed consistent over the years (define “prison” for me, you have ten seconds!).

and I've seen some discussions around the discords with other people talking about it too. Two major pieces discussed in Green Level Clearance were the idea of "Tempo" and "Prison". As I am historically a "Prison Enjoyer", I figured I'd toss my hat into the ring giving my opinion on how I frame it, as well as tempo - a very important piece of what makes a deck "prisony" to me.

My definition of "Tempo"

There's a lot of great players in GLC. I imagine that they've all got an innate understanding of tempo. However, actually putting it into words is a lot more difficult.

"Tempo is like pornography, the best definition remains 'I know it when I see it'" - KomodoCommodore

"tempo is when you type faster than the other several people" - lostgeek

"Tempo is a drinking game where you have to take a shot every time the stream commentators say tempo" - manveruppd

Ok enough of the joking responses, here are some more serious ones:

"For corp tempo is 'are you doing enough to force the runner to interact with you'. I think for runner it's harder to define because it depends upon what your route to winning is. It can be ok to not react to the corp's board if your game plan is to Deep Dive multiple times and win, for example. I think it's mostly just 'how much does this action progress you towards winning the game'" - bowlsley

"Tempo means staying one beat ahead of your opponent, such that you are able to answer the threats they present" - CyberShark

These are pretty good places to start if you want something short to work with, which is why they're here before you spend another 5 minutes reading my massive ramble. I will now proceed to write way too much below:


Starting small

I want to start with a baseline concept that strips a lot of the actual core game of netrunner away, to explain the concept of tempo more easily. We'll begin with an extremely simple baseline and work our way up from there.

Lets say that the corp has an agenda in a remote protected by a piece of ice. If they score it, they win. If it's stolen by the runner, they lose. Simple, right? The core question we'd need to answer on "who wins" is "does the runner have the ability to breach the remote"? You could also ask "does the corp have enough money+clicks to score before the runner can get into the server" as another way to figure out who wins.

For me, tempo begins by asking "what does it take for the player to win the game here" and working backwards. The corp has some sort of plan to win the game (in this case, scoring the single agenda). Tempo-based actions for the corp move to advance that plan, namely by advancing the agenda and then scoring it. There's a few other pieces to consider (does the corp have enough money to rez the ice, how many clicks do they need to score said agenda, etc), but all of those extra bits are about trying to get to the point where there's enough advancements to score the points.

Alternatively for the runner, tempo-based actions are everything that gets to breaching that server and stealing the agenda away. It's getting money to pay for a breaker. It's drawing and installing the required breakers to get in. It's the click to make the run in the first place.

Lets add some more cards into the mix. If the corp plays Seamless Launch, they can advance and score the agenda with one less click! In fact, you're paying the normal cost to advance (1 credit) and getting 2 advances in return!

Any time someone is talking about tempo, they're talking about how fast they can get to the winstate in the game. If you start adding cards to HQ or the grip that improve the speed at which you can take those actions, you're often talking about tempo-positive actions that can be made.

Ok, we've got the simple axis, but netrunner is way more complex then that. There's at least 2 agendas that are going to exist at any given time! You can't win with Government Takeover alone! You need at least 1 more point for anyone to end the game.

Lets say that the corp has 5 agendas. If they score 3, they win. If the runner steals 3, the corp loses instead. The corp has a single remote server that they can advance agendas and place ice.

So the corp wins again by doing all the tempo-based actions: Getting money and using it + their clicks to install and advance agendas one at a time.

But now lets give the runner the ability to run central servers and try to spot agendas in HQ or R&D. Suddenly, they don't need to go fetch that breaker for the defending ice. They can instead go run R&D a few times and find singles to win, or get extra agendas out of HQ while the corp advances the one in the scoring server.

We've created a whole new axis by which the runner can win. It requires a bit of luck hitting random accesses in the deck or hand, but if the runner didn't have an icebreaker it'd be a heck of a lot easier to do that vs find a breaker, install it, and run the remote. Or is it?


Building out from there

From the more complex standpoint of the game itself, tempo is all about doing actions that make it so that you can win before your opponent does, simple as that. Tempo advantage is all about who's going to win if the gamestate just kind of stays as it is.

If the runner has a "remote lock" (the money and ability to go steal/trash whatever the corporation jams into a remote), you might consider the runner to have a Tempo Advantage. If the corp can sit their agendas behind a barrier while the runner has no fracter or money, then the corp player might have a Tempo Advantage.

But to both of the above examples, there are routes to victory beyond just the question of "can the runner get into the remote". What if the runner has remote lock, but the corp is sitting on 60 credits and 3 copies of Big Deal to get 7 points really fast over three turns? What if the runner can't break into the remote, but has a Conduit with 5 virus counters and no ice defending R&D?

The obvious examples above are obvious, but these sorts of examples are few and far between in real games. Odds are the needle of "Tempo Advantage" is going to swing a lot more closely to who's "in the lead". Beyond that, resources are few and finite. Maybe the runner can go steal the 2nd agenda and get themselves to 5 points, but that brings their credit total to 0. Maybe the corp uses their one Nanomanagement to break remote-lock one time, but doesn't have another copy to use to finish the game.


What is "Tempo Positive" anyways?

Small side tangent.

Your deck's goal (whether corp or runner) is to go as fast as possible to get to the "winstate" without your opponent getting there first.

"But wait" you might ask, "glacier-style decks don't go fast at all. What's up with that? Are you just completely forgetting about a whole archetype"?

The key with tempo is the "before your opponent gets there" part of it. For a corp, sometimes that's all about scoring as fast as physically possible (see Trains rights! as a good example), but instead of that you can focus on slowing down the runner instead, usually by making a bunch of money and then making it hard for the runner to actually get accesses on cards (see old btl lists). Somewhere in the middle are decks that try to do both - they've got some expensive ice but are also trying to score as fast as possible (Nuvem is a good example).

For the runner, the common thought is that its the same regardless of ID: build up a rig and then just kind of win once you can deal with every threat. But there's are so many different variations of that plan and how it can go! Sometimes it focuses on centrals accesses, sometimes it's making overwhelming amounts of cash, sometimes its playing for the corp to lose, and sometimes it's just going as fast as physically possible to get as many accesses as possible.

Often, people will describe a play that someone makes as tempo positive. Clean Getaway to trash an important asset, Cohort Guidance Program drawing a bunch of card and making money, Trick Shot in general, that sort of thing. I see most tempo positive calls to be one or both of these things:

  • A card that does a whole bunch of click compression (stuff that might normally take 3+ clicks but instead it's all-in-one).
  • Things that give you a generic answer to a lot of problems (anything that gives a ton of money or cards are the common ones).

They're not directly solving the "how do I win" problem, they're just speeding up the rate at which you can solve said problem. You still need to install a breaker (which people often call tempo negative since it's reducing your common resource pool that solves problems) and advance agendas (which is just money and time in which you could be doing something else like making more money or using time more efficiently).

Specifically, I think most people define tempo in the short-term, which is where a lot of "positive" vs "negative" tempo comes from. In this situation, tempo is usually discussed in the "right now" moment of "can I get X points in this turn or next turn?". Point flips usually are big asks of time and resources when you think of breaking into a scoring server or advancing over 2 turns. But at the end of the day, you can think of a corp scoring 4 3/2s as "16 clicks and 12 credits of actions I need to spend as fast as possible", and actually scoring an agenda just reduces that number by 4 and 3 respectively. Short-term you're losing options for the future by spending your time and money, but long-term you have reduced the effort needed to win.

To summarize, short-term tempo is the question of "how many options of strategies can I work on during any given click" and long-term tempo is "How fast do I get to the end of the game". Staying "on-tempo" is usually referred to performing a winning move while still maintaining (or increasing) your short-term tempo (see Offworld Office).

(Edit: Honestly I don't know why I'm talking about this as short-term vs long-term tempo. If you've ever heard "tempo" vs "value" that's what this really is lol. I do think the idea of value though is that it's reducing future required tempo that you'll need to actually close out, which is a tempo in-of itself)

I think most people only talk about tempo in the short-term, so often people think that "short-term" tempo is the only tempo. But you know what? There are other long-term tempo positive things you can do as a player beyond just having a bunch of cool cards. If the corp has a 3-iced remote slow-advancing a 5/3, you know what's a tempo positive play? MULTIACCESS R&D BAYBEEEEEEEE.

Simply win before your opponent does. It's the beauty of the game that we get so many options to do that. There's always (usually) a cheaper alternative that also gives you a shot at winning. Netrunner is a game about odds more then anything, which means that due to the amount of points in a corp deck, and cards getting drawn in a particular way, and just the fact that the central servers exist, that you can always try to take the odds on a play that might get you that win faster.

(On the other side of the table, the corp can roll the dice by putting 3 Byte! in their deck and hoping you crash directly into them.)


Identifying Threats (Corp and Runner-side)

People talk about "threats" a lot, particularly on corp cards (usually assets or a few operations). But what does "Threat" even mean?

To me, I define threats as Things that cause my opponent to win faster then me.

Wow. Much generic. Very easy. Yeah, it actually kind of is that easy. The hard part is figuring out what exactly is a threat at any given time or boardstate.

Extreme case: Cohort Guidance Program is a card considered a threat for a lot of decklists: it's economy, it's advancing cards to score agendas, it powers up AU Co, and more. Overall, it speeds up the game in a way that really meshes with the corp actually winning the game. You can use it to get a bunch of money, then use it to score really quickly. What's not threatening about it?

Well, lets say the corp player has 50 credits and no cards in their deck. Ok, so we can't draw cards, and even if we could, we wouldn't really need to make money anyways. What if Archives has no facedown cards? Then we don't need to worry about cohort advancing stuff on the board. So is it really a threat there?

One of the hardest parts of netrunner is identifying a card as a threat, and then proceeding to unidentify it as a threat. Ok, Cohort speeds up the game a ton. But what if you as the runner has all your breakers and a bunch of bonus clicks and a ton of money? Does it matter that the corp is getting all this stuff if you can just steal agendas first? Who cares about Holo Man Fast Advancing 3/2s when you've got R&D locked?

The game plays to 7 points, so guess what - sometimes a threat can do something to get your opponent closer to winning the game, but you don't care because you still win before them. Who cares if Holo Man gets a 5/3 agenda scored, when you can Deep Dive twice next turn for the win?

But then there's other times where it's really bad to ignore a threat. Big Deal scoring a 5/3 from hand. Phat can set up kill lines. Oh god, we've never talked about kill lines.

You know the fastest way for a corp to win before the runner does? Sometimes it's sending a missile into their building.

You know what's also a threat? The corp scoring agendas.

To quickly hit what might be a runner-side threat when you play corp, I've got an easy one for ya. All icebreakers are threats. They let your opponent breach servers and steal points and destroy your threats.

Deep Dive and Conduit are threats. Any multiaccess means that the runner can go get points at a faster rate, which means you either need to deal with that, or speed yourself up to match.

Often multiaccess and breakers are what the corp player needs to be aware of threat-wise, but if you're playing to kill the runner, The Class Act in hand is a threat. You gotta get ready for sometimes the runner ending their turn with 9 cards in hand before you can send your kill line.

Threats are often the endgame that your resources build towards as the runner. It's considered "tempo-negative" to install a breaker, but you do it so you can actually win the game. The reason people think its tempo negative is because you now have less resources to install your other breakers, or your multiaccess, or whatever else. You need more "tempo-positive" cards to make up the difference econ-wise.

As a corp, you often are "spending tempo" to set up a threat by defending it with ice. Runners need to get breakers and install them and get money to pay for them to get through, so with 1 card you're often forcing the runner to do a whole bunch of different stuff just to see your sweet sweet threat.


TL;DR

Ok I've written enough about my thoughts on tempo, lets try to wrap it all into a nice bow.

Tempo is the rate at which a player is winning the game. You try to build tempo to get to your wincon faster then your opponent can get to their wincon.

See? Simple as that.

Anyways what was the original thing I wanted to talk about again?

Oh yeah, Prison.

Defining Prison

Ok, so I wanted to define tempo because it's a core aspect of what prison is. I'm going to mainly talk about it from the corp side because that's often where it shows up in netrunner.

You see, in a normal game of netrunner, tempo swings back and forth, and it isn't something that's easy to identify. Sure, you can say "the runner is ahead here" or "the corp seems to have it" but there's too many options for a player to take that gives them a chance at victory, even if all hope seems lost. Sometimes the corp will jam random assets into the scoring server and try to tax the runner out of credits enough to actually safely put points in. Sometimes the runner just hits the top of R&D with their last click and steals a 5/3 off the top.

Netrunner is an odds game. By building tempo you are increasing your odds to win. Alternatively, when your opponent gains tempo, they increase their odds to win. You can play from a dominating position, but there's usually some sort of way for your opponent to roll the dice and just pray that they hit it. It won't happen often, but it's possible. It's also how some of the best games have ended (see Worlds 2024 finals as a good example).

Prison decks are decks that attempt to mathematically bring that chance for your opponent to 0%.


What does that even mean?

Let me use my old deck IcyHot as a clear example.

There is a line with 3 Cold Site Server, 3 Warm Reception, and a Front Company, where it is mechanically impossible for the runner to make runs. Like, it would cost the runner 10 clicks to make a run and there is no way they could do that.

These are the lines that prison works to. They focus not on their win percentages, and instead dial the needle in a way that makes your opponent's win odds as close to null as possible. Not every prison deck mathematically has the aspect that actually can get runner win rate to null, but often there will be edge cases in prison decks where 0 win percentage happens.

For example, lets say you're playing a deck with a rezzed Phat and Hostile Architecture, with a bunch of 1 and 2 pointers. If the runner only has 4 points, and 0 cards in their grip or stack, it is physically impossible for them to win, as they'll steal an agenda and instantly die. They can't trash the Phat too (or the hostile) as the damage will kill them in that situation as well. Congratulations! You've made a prison lockout.

Prison decks focus on these sorts of lockouts. They might involve a huge amount of rigshooting in which it becomes impossible for a runner to get back into servers at some point. It may involve decking them out and then making the only possible points to steal Obokata, or going through a Kakugo. Regardless, it doesn't really matter what the corp's plan to actually win the game is, they just get the runner to lose and work their way from there.

You might consider glacier to be a form of prison, but I refute that. For most glacier decks, if you go too slowly to actually score out and win, the runner can theoretically set up their entire rig, start clicking for credits, and just wait for you to begin jamming agendas. You do need to do your thing at some point, or you'll just deck out and die. There's no stopping the runner from making a run at some point in the game.

I will comment that a generic kill list that focuses on flatline is not the runner "losing" in the same sense, as they can usually do things to play around it (draw cards, pay for traces, see agendas first, etc). A lot of tagging lists still give lines for the runner to go steal stuff before the bad starts happening to them, so I don't consider those archetypes to be prison. Sometimes they could be though, if the tag line involves the runner NEVER BEING ABLE TO RUN AGAIN. B-1001 is close to this, but like you could always just kinda go and trash it in most lists where it exists so idk. Also its hard to give 50 tags nowadays so they run out eventually. Maybe someone will make a B-1001 tag prison deck at some point in the future. I hope not.

That's the main thing I use to define prison. If your core gameplan is not to win but instead trying to get your opponent to lose, you're playing prison. Congrats!

Conclusion

So yeah, Tempo and Prison. On one hand, you've got "how fast am I winning", and on the other, you've got "how can I get my opponent to just lose". This writeup obviously took more then 10 seconds to put together, so I didn't achieve Tuno's goal of making it really easy to figure out, but I hope this helps others get some understanding of what others might mean when they use these phrases.

Alrighty, time to go play my prisony rigshooty lockout ob at my local meetup. It's not really prison, but like, I think people hate this sort of thing about as much as old prison. Maybe I should include that in my definition...